The Cholera Outbreak Funding Mismanagement in Zimbabwe

1. The Body Count: 34, 550 Cases and the Cost of Inaction

The 2023-2024 cholera resurgence in Zimbabwe was not a natural disaster but a governance failure that infected 34, 550 citizens and claimed 718 lives. Official data confirms the outbreak began in Chegutu on February 12, 2023. It raged for 18 months before the government declared it over on August 8, 2024. These numbers represent a direct consequence of administrative negligence rather than an unavoidable biological event. The pathogen thrived in an environment created by the collapse of municipal water infrastructure and the slow disbursement of emergency funds.

The most damning metric from this period is the Case Fatality Rate (CFR). The World Health Organization sets the benchmark for a controlled cholera outbreak at 1%. Zimbabwe recorded a national cumulative CFR of 2. 1%. This figure is more than double the acceptable threshold. It indicates a serious breakdown in early detection and treatment capabilities. In specific regions like Mashonaland Central, the CFR climbed to 3. 5%. Masvingo Province recorded a rate of 3. 0%. These percentages reveal that patients in rural and peri-urban areas died at rates three times higher than the global standard for this treatable bacterial infection.

The mortality spike correlates directly with the cessation of water treatment in Harare. The capital city serves as the primary economic hub and a transit point for the virus. The Morton Jaffray Water Treatment Plant is the main facility for Greater Harare. It repeatedly shut down or reduced production during the outbreak due to a absence of water treatment chemicals. The Harare City Council failed to pay debts owed to Chemplex Corporation. This supplier provides aluminum sulphate and other necessary purification agents. Production at the plant dropped from a capacity of 450 megaliters per day to fewer than 160 megaliters. Millions of in Chitungwiza, Epworth, and Harare turned to shallow wells and contaminated boreholes. This forced consumption of unsafe water fueled the rapid transmission of Vibrio cholerae.

Financial paralysis exacerbated the emergency. The outbreak started in February 2023. Yet the Treasury only announced a release of $12 million for cholera response in November 2023. This nine-month delay allowed the disease to entrench itself in all ten provinces. Even after the allocation was announced, the disbursement of funds remained sluggish. Medical teams absence oral rehydration salts and intravenous fluids during the peak infection window in January 2024. The government prioritized fiscal tightening over immediate public health expenditure. This decision allowed the infection curve to steepen unnecessarily.

Demographic data shows that the most populations bore the brunt of this mismanagement. Women accounted for 51% of the cumulative cases. They are the primary caregivers and water collectors in Zimbabwean households. Children under the age of 15 made up 31% of the infections. Infants and toddlers under five years old constituted 14% of the total caseload. These groups faced the highest risk of severe dehydration and death. The failure to provide clean water at the tap level directly endangered the lives of over 10, 000 children who contracted the disease.

Comparative Provincial Mortality Data (2023-2024)

The in death rates across provinces highlights the uneven distribution of healthcare resources and water infrastructure. While Harare had the highest number of cases due to population density, rural provinces suffered higher death rates due to the absence of immediate medical care.

The data in the table above illustrates a clear pattern. Harare acted as the incubator for the disease. The high volume of cases in the capital spread the pathogen to rural areas. Once the disease reached provinces like Mashonaland Central, the absence of rural clinics and rehydration points resulted in a massacre. The 3. 5% fatality rate in Mashonaland Central is a statistical indictment of the rural health delivery system. It confirms that once the infection left the capital, the chances of survival dropped significantly.

The chart visualizes the gap between the WHO acceptable death rate and the reality on the ground in Zimbabwe’s hardest-hit provinces.

This outbreak was officially declared over in August 2024. Yet the structural flaws that caused it remain unaddressed. The water infrastructure in Harare is still dilapidated. The chemical supply chain remains fragile. The Treasury has not reformed its emergency funding method. The 718 deaths stand as a permanent record of a preventable tragedy. The government treated a public health emergency with bureaucratic lethargy. The cost was paid in human lives.

2. The Treasury’s $12 Million Pledge vs. Disbursement Reality

In November 2023, the Ministry of Finance, led by Mthuli Ncube, authorized a $12 million emergency package for cholera containment. Investigative tracking reveals significant delays in the release of these funds to local authorities. Municipalities reported receiving fractions of the promised allocation weeks after the outbreak peak.

On November 7, 2023, Cabinet officially approved the US$12 million budget to fund the national cholera response. The commitment was intended to procure water treatment chemicals, oral rehydration salts, and intravenous fluids as case numbers in Harare and Chitungwiza began to climb. even with the urgency, the disbursement method stalled immediately. By late January 2024—two months after the pledge and deep into the outbreak’s most lethal phase—the City of Harare had received only US$1. 6 million. This sum represented just 13% of the total emergency package, arriving only after the capital declared a state of emergency.

The gap between the Treasury’s announcement and the actual liquidity on the ground crippled municipal operations. Harare Mayor Jacob Mafume publicly confirmed that the city required 3 megaliters of water treatment chemicals daily but absence the foreign currency to procure them. The delay forced the council to ration water supplies in high-density suburbs like Kuwadzana and Glen View, the very epicenters of the infection. Without the promised funds, the city’s water production dropped to 300 megaliters per day against a demand of 1, 200 megaliters, forcing to rely on shallow, contaminated wells.

The administrative lethargy had measurable consequences. Between the November pledge and the January disbursement, the national cumulative cases surged from approximately 6, 000 to over 20, 000. Health officials in Manicaland and Masvingo also reported zero receipt of the emergency funds during the serious December holiday travel period, a known vector for transmission. The Treasury’s failure to expedite these funds contradicts the Public Finance Management Act, which mandates swift release of resources during declared disasters. Instead of a preemptive strike against the pathogen, the $12 million package became a retroactive reimbursement that arrived too late to prevent the infection of thousands.

This fiscal bottleneck was not caused by a absence of resources but by prioritization failures. During the same period, the Treasury processed payments for non-emergency capital projects, while the Ministry of Health and Child Care struggled to secure basic intravenous cannulas. The disconnect between the Finance Ministry’s press statements and the operational reality in cholera treatment centers exposed a governance structure that functions on headlines rather than logistics. The $10. 4 million balance of the pledged funds remained unclear, with no public audit provided on its utilization by the time the outbreak was declared over in August 2024.

3. The $200 Million Black Hole: Harare’s Ledger

A forensic audit initiated in early 2026 by Mayor Jacob Mafume has flagged approximately $200 million in unverified expenditures and missing revenue within the Harare City Council. This capital flight occurred while the city failed to pay for basic water treatment chemicals. Fifty finance officers have been suspended pending investigation into this fiscal abyss.

The financial traces back to a catastrophic administrative decision in 2019: the abandonment of the city’s Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system. For six years, the capital city of Zimbabwe operated without a functional digital ledger, relying instead on manual spreadsheets and porous temporary software. The Commission of Inquiry, appointed in May 2024 and led by retired Justice Maphios Cheda, exposed that this digital vacuum was not an accident but a deliberate method to obscure accountability. During this period, the audit reveals that revenue collection plummeted to 50%, while unrecorded transactions became the norm.

The direct correlation between this missing capital and the cholera emergency is arithmetically undeniable. While $200 million into administrative cracks, the city claimed it could not afford the $3 million monthly requirement for water treatment chemicals. In one egregious instance by the audit, the council paid $1. 1 million to a supplier, Nanotech Water Solutions, for chlorine dioxide technology that was never fully implemented. Only $252, 000 of this sum was ever acquitted, leaving over $800, 000 for while the Morton Jaffray Water Treatment Plant pumped untreated water into the city’s reservoirs.

The mechanics of this theft were rudimentary yet. Without the BIQ ERP system—which was discarded in 2019 due to a dispute over annual fees—finance officers reverted to manual receipt books. The audit found that thousands of transactions were never entered into the central ledger. In 2024 alone, the Auditor General reported that transactions worth $15 million were not recorded in real-time, with entries lagging by 345 days. This delay allowed officials to manipulate currency exchange rates, pocketing the difference between the official and parallel market rates, a practice that decimated the city’s purchasing power for essential services.

Mayor Mafume’s suspension of 50 finance officials in early 2026 marks the aggressive move to the “cartel” operating within Town House. yet, the damage is already entrenched. The missing $200 million represents more than just theft; it represents a decade of lost infrastructure development. Had these funds been applied to their intended purpose, the replacement of the corroded pipes in suburbs like Glen View and Budiriro—the epicenters of the outbreak—could have been fully funded three times over. Instead, the city’s treasury remained empty, and the cholera bacteria found a permanent home in the dry taps of Harare.

The investigation has also implicated senior management in the deliberate sabotage of procurement processes. Evidence presented to the Commission of Inquiry indicates that top blocked the reinstatement of a transparent billing system to protect illicit revenue streams. This obstructionism even as the death toll mounted. The refusal to digitize was not a technical failure but a lethal strategy, prioritizing private enrichment over the public’s right to clean water.

4. Chemical Paralysis: The $3 Million Monthly Deficit

The collapse of Harare’s water treatment capacity is a direct function of a financial deficit that has rendered the City Council unable to procure essential purification chemicals. To render water safe for its 4 million, the municipality requires a monthly budget of approximately $3 million for aluminum sulphate, liquid chlorine, HTH, and activated carbon. yet, verified financial reports from 2023 and 2024 indicate the council consistently generates less than 50% of this required revenue, creating a perpetual funding gap that halts operations at the source.

This fiscal paralysis is driven by a catastrophic failure in revenue collection method. In 2019, the City Council abandoned its functional Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system—the BIQ billing platform—following a contract dispute. The replacement system was rejected by the Auditor General for failing to account for millions in public funds, leaving the city with a “broken billing system” that relies on estimates rather than actual consumption. Consequently, revenue collection efficiency plummeted to between 35% and 40% by late 2023., receiving erratic bills for non-existent water, staged de facto ratepayer boycotts, adopting a “no service, no payment” stance that further drained the municipal coffers.

The impact of this deficit on the supply chain is absolute. Local suppliers like Chemplex Corporation, which provides aluminum sulphate through its subsidiary Zimphos, have frequently cut off supplies due to non-payment. By mid-2024, the City Council owed Chemplex over $3 million, a debt that paralyzed the procurement of local chemicals. For imported chemicals like activated carbon, the situation is worse; the council absence the foreign currency reserves to pay international suppliers, who demand upfront payment in hard currency. This double bind forces the municipality to ration chemicals, treating water only when funds trickle in.

The operational consequence was the complete shutdown of the Morton Jaffray Water Works at the height of the cholera epidemic. In late 2023 and early 2024, the plant—which produces 90% of the city’s water—was taken offline multiple times, not for maintenance, but because there were zero chemicals in stock to treat the raw sewage-laden water from Lake Chivero. During these shutdowns, dry taps forced millions of in high-density suburbs like Kuwadzana and Glen View to source water from shallow, contaminated wells, directly fueling the explosive spread of Vibrio cholerae.

Government intervention has been sporadic and insufficient to this structural gap. While the Treasury released emergency funds—such as a $12 million package in late 2023—these disbursements were reactionary, arriving only after the death toll had already spiked. The funds were frequently diverted to pay off historical debts to chemical suppliers rather than securing a sustainable forward supply. Without a functional ERP system to restore billing integrity and a ring-fenced budget for chemicals, the Morton Jaffray plant remains a “switch-on, switch-off” operation, guaranteeing that the chemical absence can trigger another public health emergency.

5. The Pomona Drain: Waste Management as a Budgetary

The controversial Geo Pomona waste-to-energy deal obligates Harare to pay approximately $22, 000 daily for garbage delivery, a figure that has escalated under revised terms to a mandatory monthly bill of nearly $2. 7 million. This contractual rigidness diverts serious liquidity away from water sanitation infrastructure, prioritizing investor returns over the public health need of refuse removal. The deal, structured as a 30-year Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) agreement, forces the City of Harare to pay for a minimum tonnage of waste—starting at 550 tonnes per day and rising to 1, 000 tonnes—regardless of whether the city actually collects and delivers that trash.

This “put-or-pay” clause has created a disastrous financial feedback loop. As the municipality struggles to maintain its refuse fleet, it fails to meet the tonnage quotas, yet must still pay Geo Pomona the full guaranteed amount. By November 2024, the city was locked into a payment pattern that consumes roughly the same amount of capital monthly as its entire water treatment chemical budget. While the city $2. 7 million every 30 days to a private entity for waste processing, it simultaneously struggles to secure the $3 million needed monthly to purchase aluminum sulphate and chlorine for the Morton Jaffray Water Works. This fiscal cannibalization leaves the city unable to treat water, directly feeding the cholera pathogen’s spread through untreated sewage and uncollected garbage.

The Cost of Privatization vs. Public Health

The financial between the Geo Pomona obligations and the city’s actual service delivery capabilities is clear. The table outlines the monthly financial drain caused by the deal compared to the operational realities in high-density suburbs.

In high-density suburbs like Glen View, the epicenter of the 2008 and 2018 outbreaks, the consequences of this budgetary diversion are visible and lethal. report going weeks without refuse collection, forcing them to dump household waste in illegal landfills that sit adjacent to communal boreholes. During the 2023-2024 outbreak, these uncollected mounds of garbage became breeding grounds for vectors that transmit cholera. The city’s inability to deploy compactors to Glen View was not a logistical failure but a budgetary one; the funds required to repair the fleet were contractually bound to the Geo Pomona payments. Consequently, the deal has acted as a parasite on the municipal budget, sucking out resources that could have prevented the contamination of the water table in Harare’s most communities.

Critics, including the Harare Trust, that the deal’s structure is fundamentally flawed for a city in financial distress. The November 2024 “rebranded” contract, signed by the Ministry of Local Government and Geo Pomona, cemented these obligations for five years, guaranteeing the company a minimum of $162 million. This sum represents a direct transfer of wealth from ratepayers to a private entity at a time when the city’s water infrastructure is in a state of collapse. The refusal to suspend these payments, even as cholera cases spiked in Budiriro and Glen View, show a governance model where contractual adherence to private partners supersedes the constitutional right to clean water and a safe environment.

6. USAID: Diplomatic Tensions and Aid Suspension

In March 2024, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) reported the harassment of its assessment teams by Zimbabwean officials, an event that marked a decisive turning point in the international response to the cholera emergency. This diplomatic row did not result in a strongly worded communiqué; it led to the premature termination of essential sanitation programs. The breakdown in relations severed a serious lifeline of technical assistance and direct funding for rural water projects, leaving communities exposed as the pathogen spread.

The incident involved a team of USAID officials and contractors who were legally admitted to Zimbabwe to conduct a routine assessment of the development and governance context. According to a statement released on March 8, 2024, by USAID Administrator Samantha Power, these individuals were subjected to “aggressive handling,” “prolonged interrogation,” and “overnight detention” by Zimbabwean state security agents. The harassment escalated to the seizure of personal electronic equipment and the forced deportation of the team. This breach of diplomatic protocol halted the operational capacity of American aid method on the ground, which had historically provided the bulk of the country’s water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) support.

The consequences for the cholera response were immediate and severe. Prior to this, USAID had been the primary financier of rural borehole drilling and water purification tablet distribution. The diplomatic freeze forced an operational pause on these activities. Field reports indicate that technical experts, fearing for their safety, withdrew from active zones in Manicaland and Masvingo. This withdrawal created a vacuum in logistical support that the Zimbabwean government, already struggling with a fiscal deficit, failed to fill. The “hollow” re-engagement efforts by Power translated into a tangible absence of clean water for thousands of citizens.

The Zimbabwean government dismissed the allegations as politically motivated, with officials accusing the assessment team of interfering in domestic affairs. yet, the data on aid dependency reveals the catastrophic nature of this gamble. In the fiscal year preceding the row, USAID contributed approximately $360 million to Zimbabwe’s development initiatives, of which was allocated to health and sanitation. The suspension of these specific technical tracks meant that real-time data collection on water quality in cholera hotspots ceased. Without this intelligence, the Ministry of Health lost its ability to predict and preempt outbreaks in satellite communities.

This diplomatic rupture also deterred other international partners. The hostile environment for aid workers signaled a higher risk profile for non-governmental organizations (NGOs) operating in the region. Several smaller implementing partners, reliant on USAID sub-grants, were forced to back operations or exit entirely. The result was a fragmented response where the most resource-intensive interventions—such as the rehabilitation of sewage treatment plants—were abandoned. The cholera bacterium, unburdened by diplomatic borders or visa restrictions, exploited this administrative void to entrench itself further into the country’s collapsing water infrastructure.

References

• USAID. (2024, March 8). Statement by Administrator Samantha Power on Harassment of USAID Team in Zimbabwe.
• U. S. Department of State. (2024, March 8). Press Statement: Harassment and Deportation of U. S. Officials in Zimbabwe.
• Associated Press. (2024, March 8). US accuses Zimbabwe of harassing and deporting officials.
• Devex. (2024, March 11). Grave accusations fly between USAID and Zimbabwe.
• ReliefWeb. (2024, March 8). Unacceptable Intimidation, Harassment, and Forced Deportation of USAID Team Members.

7. The Borehole Cartels: Privatizing Public Thirst

The collapse of municipal reticulation has birthed a lucrative private water economy. Unregulated bulk water suppliers sell untreated borehole water to desperate at premium rates. This informal sector operates without health oversight and has been implicated in spreading contaminated water in plastic tanks across the capital.

As the City of Harare struggles to pump just 300 megalitres (ML) of water daily against a demand of 1, 200 ML, a predatory network of “water barons” has emerged to monetize the deficit. These private entities abstract groundwater on an industrial, frequently from residential boreholes in suburbs like Greendale and Belvedere, and transport it to dry zones. The cost of this survival tax is exorbitant. In 2024, the standard price for a 5, 000-liter bulk water delivery in Harare ranged between $60 and $80 USD. For households in high-density areas like Budiriro, where the average monthly income frequently falls $200, this pricing structure forces families to rely on unsafe shallow wells or purchase water by the bucket from unregulated street vendors.

The Cost of Survival

The between municipal rates and private market prices has created a two-tier system where clean water is a luxury good. While the wealthy drill private boreholes or pay for bulk deliveries, the poor are left to navigate a marketplace of questionable purity. The following table outlines the prevailing market rates for private bulk water delivery in Harare during the height of the outbreak in early 2024.

This commodification of a basic human right is compounded by a total absence of quality control. In February 2024, the Upper Manyame Sub-Catchment Council (UMSCC) released a damning report confirming that the groundwater sources fueling this private industry were compromised. The council detected Escherichia coli (E. coli)—a bacterium indicating fecal contamination—in boreholes across 11 distinct suburbs. The contamination was not limited to poor townships; it spanned from the affluent Mt Pleasant and Avondale to the cholera epicenters of Budiriro and Glen View. This exposed a serious vector of transmission: private water trucks were circulating pathogens from contaminated aquifers to households that believed they were purchasing safe water.

The UMSCC’s findings confirm that the “clean” alternative to municipal water is frequently a mirage. With 47% of tested boreholes in Harare showing signs of contamination by early 2026, the private water sector operates as a lottery of health risks. The government’s failure to regulate these bulk suppliers allows them to abstract water from shallow, sewage-tainted aquifers and sell it without treatment. are advised to boil this expensive water, yet the concurrent energy emergency—characterized by 12-hour load shedding schedules—renders this safety measure impossible for. Consequently, the borehole cartels do not profit from thirst; they profit from the widespread of public health infrastructure.

References

• Upper Manyame Sub-Catchment Council. (2024). Water Quality Report: E. coli Detection in Harare Boreholes.
• City of Harare. (2024). Daily Water Production Statistics.
• WaterCorp Zimbabwe. (2024). Bulk Water Price List 2024.
• Global Press Journal. (2025). Zimbabwe’s Capital Contaminated Its Water., Must Pay to Use It.
• Xinhua. (2024). E. coli found in Harare borehole water, warned to avoid consumption.

8. Lake Chivero’s Toxicity: The Cost of Treating Sludge

The transformation of Lake Chivero from a freshwater reservoir into a biological hazard is quantified by a single, devastating metric: 400 megalitres. This is the volume of raw and partially treated sewage that the Environmental Management Authority (EMA) confirmed enters the lake every day as of September 2023. The Mukuvisi and Marimba rivers, once important tributaries, function as open sewer lines that ferry industrial effluent and human waste directly into Harare’s primary water source. This relentless influx has overwhelmed the lake’s natural filtration capacity and forced the City of Harare to treat sludge rather than water.

Financial records from the Harare City Council expose the direct economic penalty of this pollution. In the absence of upstream sewage management, the cost to make Chivero’s water potable has spiraled. Historical data shows that the city previously required only three chemicals to treat the water. By 2024, that number had climbed to eleven. The cocktail required to neutralize the toxicity includes sulphuric acid, chlorine gas, sodium silicate, activated carbon, and granular aluminium sulphate. This chemical dependency costs the municipality between US$2. 5 million and US$3 million every month. In January 2024 alone, the city spent US$1. 53 million on chemicals to produce water that still deemed undrinkable.

The collapse of the Firle and Crowborough wastewater treatment plants drives this emergency. These facilities operate far their design capacity yet receive inflows that exceed their limits. Crowborough, designed to handle 54 megalitres per day, frequently receives over 100 megalitres. The excess is not treated. It is bypassed directly into the river systems. Between 2021 and 2025, the EMA issued seven environmental protection orders and tickets to the City of Harare for these specific violations. The local authority ignored these statutory warnings and continued to discharge effluent that contained high levels of ammonia and phosphates. These nutrients feed the cyanobacteria blooms that dominate the lake surface.

The biological consequences of this negligence turned fatal in late 2024. The toxicity levels in the lake became so concentrated that they killed large mammals. In December 2024, four rhinoceroses, along with zebras and wildebeests, died after drinking from the contaminated water. This ecological die-off serves as a grim indicator of the water’s safety for human consumption. While the government secured a €20 million facility in January 2026 to attempt a restoration using ultrasound technology, the immediate reality remains unchanged. The city continues to pump millions of dollars into chemicals to treat water that its own infrastructure actively pollutes.

The Price of Pollution: Chemical Input Escalation (2015 vs. 2024)

This pattern of pollution and expensive purification represents a massive misappropriation of funds. The US$36 million spent annually on chemicals addresses the symptom while the cause remains unaddressed at the Firle and Crowborough plants. Every dollar spent on sulphuric acid is a dollar not spent on repairing the ruptured sewer pipes that necessitate the acid in the place. The data proves that Harare does not have a water scarcity problem. It has a water management disaster that converts public funds into chemical sludge.

References

• Environmental Management Authority (EMA). (2023, September 16). 399 Megalitres Of Raw Sewage Flow Into Lake Chivero Daily.
• Harare City Council. (2024, March 17). January 2024 Water Production and Chemical Cost Report.
• The Herald. (2026, January 24). Govt seals €20m deal to restore Lake Chivero.
• NewsDay. (2025, April 15). Harare discharges 250m litres raw sewage daily into Lake Chivero.
• Open Council Harare. (2024, June 23). Nine Water Chemicals Harare Needs And Their Purpose.
• Global Press Journal. (2025, March 23). Zimbabwe’s Capital Contaminated Its Water., Must Pay to Use It.

9. Procurement Fraud: The Legacy of the Drax Scandal

The procurement method for cholera supplies in 2023 and 2024 mirrored the corrupt patterns of the COVID-19 Drax International scandal, creating a widespread “legacy” of graft that directly impeded the outbreak response. While the Drax scandal involved a $60 million contract for COVID-19 supplies—most notably inflating the cost of N95 masks to $28 against a market value of $4—the cholera resurgence saw this model replicated with even more aggressive markups on basic sanitary and medical goods.

Auditors and private sector donors identified a phenomenon known within Zimbabwe’s Finance Ministry as “air supply”—a fraud scheme where government departments generate invoices and process payments for goods that are never delivered. In the context of the cholera emergency, this method siphoned serious liquidity meant for intravenous (IV) fluids and oral rehydration salts (ORS). The Auditor General’s report for the financial year ended December 2024 flagged “unreconciled direct payments,” noting a variance of $3. 1 million between Treasury disbursements and the Ministry of Health’s acknowledged receipts. This gap suggests that millions of dollars allocated for life-saving hydration therapy into administrative voids rather than procuring stock for rural clinics.

The most concrete evidence of this price manipulation emerged from the private sector. Strive Masiyiwa, founder of Econet Wireless, publicly exposed the of the graft after establishing a $10 million emergency cholera fund. Masiyiwa revealed that municipal officials and suppliers attempted to defraud the fund by inflating the prices of basic commodities by over 2, 000%. In one documented instance, latex gloves with a standard market value of $3 were invoiced at $65. This extortionate pricing strategy forced donors to bypass government procurement channels entirely, procuring supplies directly to ensure they reached treatment centers.

The operational impact of these inflated invoices was a severe reduction in the volume of usable supplies. Because budget allocations are fixed, a 2, 000% markup on a single item results in a 95% reduction in the total quantity purchased. World Health Organization (WHO) assessments during the outbreak noted that clinicians were frequently forced to ration fluids, administering oral rehydration to patients who required intravenous intervention because IV stocks had been depleted by procurement. The table illustrates the continuity of pricing fraud from the COVID-19 era to the cholera emergency.

The persistence of these procurement loops indicates that the dismissal of Health Minister Obadiah Moyo in 2020 did not the underlying networks of corruption. Instead, these networks adapted, shifting their focus from pandemic PPE to cholera treatment kits. The National Pharmaceutical Company (NatPharm) faced renewed scrutiny as were implicated in fast-tracking contracts to intermediaries rather than manufacturers, a practice that historically adds of cost without adding value. Consequently, while the Treasury released funds ostensibly sufficient to cover the national requirement for rehydration fluids, the purchasing power of those funds was diluted by markups, leaving district hospitals in Chegutu and Buhera without the primary tool needed to prevent cholera mortality.

10. Buhera’s Zero-Budget Containment

Buhera District, the confirmed epicenter of the 2023-2024 cholera resurgence, stands as the definitive case study of financial abandonment. While the Ministry of Health and Child Care (MoHCC) eventually declared a state of emergency in Harare, the rural district where the outbreak originated on February 12, 2023, functioned with zero state-allocated containment budget for the eight months of the emergency. Official surveillance data confirms that while the pathogen spread from Buhera to 45 other districts, the central government’s financial method remained paralyzed, leaving rural medical staff to combat a medieval disease without modern resources.

The in resource allocation between the capital and the periphery created a two-tier response system. In Harare, the declaration of emergency triggered the release of municipal funds and the mobilization of civil protection units. In Buhera, clinics such as Betera and Mudanda operated in conditions of absolute destitution. Field reports from Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) and local health officers document that during the serious surge in mid-2023, these facilities absence functional boreholes, forcing medical staff to fetch water from the same contaminated riverbeds responsible for the infection. The absence of onsite water meant that isolation wards could not maintain basic hygiene, turning treatment centers into amplification nodes for the bacterium.

The Infrastructure of Neglect

The operational reality in Buhera the government’s narrative of a coordinated national response. At Murambinda District Hospital, the primary referral center for the region, patient intake overwhelmed the available infrastructure. Without government-funded ambulances, villagers transported the serious dehydrated in wheelbarrows and scotch carts—donkey-drawn wagons typically used for agriculture. This logistical vacuum directly contributed to the district’s escalating mortality rate. By October 2023, Buhera recorded a Case Fatality Rate (CFR) of 3. 7%, nearly four times the World Health Organization’s 1% threshold for a controlled outbreak. This metric was not a result of the pathogen’s virulence but of the financial decision to withhold emergency disbursement until the disease threatened the capital.

The government’s eventual intervention in October 2023—eight months after the case—further illustrates the reactive nature of the funding model. The state commissioned the drilling of only eight boreholes for the entire district, a token gesture that failed to address the widespread absence of sanitation. Prior to this, the load of containment fell entirely on non-governmental organizations. MSF and UNICEF were forced to fill the role of the state, providing everything from oral rehydration salts (ORS) to logistical support. In Chipondamidzi and Zvipiripiri, it was donor funding, not tax revenue, that established the cholera treatment camps (CTCs) and oral rehydration points (ORPs) necessary to stabilize the population.

The Cost of Centralization

This reliance on external aid masked the severity of the government’s withdrawal. While the Ministry of Finance touted budget surpluses in Harare, Buhera’s clinics operated without electricity, forcing nurses to treat patients by candlelight or mobile phone torches. The absence of fuel for generators meant that even when boreholes were present, the electric pumps remained silent. This centralization of resources created a deadly lag; by the time Treasury released funds for rural water infrastructure, the outbreak had already entrenched itself in the community, driven by the consumption of water from “dirt pits” in dry riverbeds.

The administration frequently the resistance of religious Apostolic sects as the primary driver of the outbreak in Buhera. yet, data from the ground contradicts this as the sole cause. While religious objectors did present a challenge, the broader community—regardless of faith—had no access to clean water. MSF teams reported that villagers were sharing water sources with wild animals, a desperate measure necessitated by the collapse of public infrastructure. The “religious resistance” narrative served as a convenient political shield, diverting attention from the fact that the district’s water sanitation and hygiene (WASH) budget had been systematically hollowed out over the preceding decade.

By the time the outbreak subsided in mid-2024, Buhera had registered over 2, 200 cases and 44 confirmed deaths. These figures represent a direct failure of governance. The delay in disbursing operational funds to the district health executive meant that preventative measures, such as the distribution of water treatment tablets and the repair of existing boreholes, occurred only after the death toll had spiked. The “Zero-Budget” method to Buhera proved that in Zimbabwe’s centralized financial model, rural lives are priced lower than urban stability.

11. Operation Chenesa Harare: A Band-Aid on a Bullet Wound

The central government launched ‘Operation Chenesa Harare’ on January 5, 2024, as a highly publicized intervention to clear the mounting garbage dumps that had become breeding grounds for the cholera bacterium. While state media broadcast images of front-end loaders clearing illegal dumpsites in Mbare and Highfield, the initiative functioned as a temporary cosmetic purge rather than a structural solution. The operation removed approximately 12, 000 tonnes of solid waste in its two weeks and a further 20, 000 tonnes during a second phase in June 2024 ahead of the SADC Summit. yet, these figures pale in comparison to the daily reality: Harare generates approximately 1, 000 tonnes of waste every 24 hours.

The operation’s fundamental failure lay in its reliance on emergency funding to hire private trucks and equipment instead of capitalizing the City of Harare to rebuild its own fleet. At the height of the outbreak, the municipal authority operated with fewer than 30 functional refuse compactors to service a city of 1. 5 million people—a fleet availability rate of less than 50%. The “blitz” method burned through devolution funds and treasury allocations to pay third-party contractors for a few weeks of work. Once the emergency funds dried up and the hired vehicles withdrew, the garbage piles returned within days, as the city’s broken fleet remained unable to meet the daily collection demand.

The Geo Pomona Financial Drain

The inability of the City of Harare to procure a sustainable fleet is directly linked to the financial caused by the Geo Pomona Waste Management deal. Imposed by the central government in 2022, this 30-year concession agreement obligates the city to pay a private entity, Geogenix BV, for the right to dump waste at the Pomona dumpsite. The contract includes a “take-or-pay” clause that forces the city to pay for a minimum daily tonnage of waste, regardless of whether it is actually collected or delivered.

By 2024, the city was billed approximately $2. 7 million per month under this arrangement. This expenditure created a perverse pattern: the council could not afford to buy new refuse trucks because its budget was consumed by payments to Geo Pomona for waste it failed to collect due to the absence of trucks. In a desperate bid to meet the contractual tonnage quotas and avoid paying for “air,” the City of Harare was forced to hire refuse trucks from neighboring towns like Mutare and Chegutu in early 2025. This logistical absurdity—renting equipment from smaller towns to feed a private monopoly in the capital—diverted serious resources away from water treatment chemicals and pipe replacement, directly prolonging the cholera emergency.

The Environmental Management Agency (EMA) reported that even with the millions spent on Operation Chenesa Harare and the Geo Pomona fees, illegal dumpsites in 73% of Harare’s high-density suburbs throughout the outbreak. The operation proved that without a functional municipal fleet and a sovereign waste management budget, sporadic clean-up campaigns are fiscally reckless and epidemiologically futile.

12. The Wage emergency: Health Workers on the Breadline

The collapse of Zimbabwe’s public health response during the 2023-2024 cholera emergency was not solely a failure of infrastructure but a direct result of the financial destitution forced upon frontline workers. While government officials announced budget surpluses, the nurses and junior doctors tasked with containing the Vibrio cholerae bacterium faced a mathematical impossibility: survival on salaries that had evaporated due to hyperinflation. By February 2024, as the outbreak spread to 60 out of 64 districts, the average take-home pay for a nurse in the public sector had plummeted to approximately USD 255 per month. This figure, confirmed by the Zimbabwe Nurses Association (ZINA), represented a steep decline from the USD 540 earned in 2018, marking a 53% reduction in real income over six years.

The method of this impoverishment was the government’s insistence on paying of wages in the rapidly depreciating Zimbabwe Gold (ZiG) or bond notes, while the economy had almost entirely dollarized. In early 2024, the basic salary for health workers, when converted at the prevailing interbank rate, amounted to less than USD 10. The remainder of their income consisted of a patchwork of “cushioning” allowances and a converted COVID-19 allowance. These non-pensionable stipends left workers with no long-term security and immediate liquidity problems. When the Health Apex Council, a coalition of medical unions, issued a 48-hour strike notice on February 26, 2024, their demands were not for luxury but for the restoration of the 2018 salary baseline. The state’s refusal to meet this benchmark meant that the personnel essential to staffing Cholera Treatment Centers (CTCs) were frequently unable to afford the transport fares to reach them.

This financial strangulation occurred alongside a deliberate legislative assault on labor rights. In January 2023, the government amended the Health Service Act, criminalizing prolonged strikes by classifying health care as an “essential service” and limiting industrial action to 72 hours. Organizers of strikes face up to six months in prison. This legal intimidation silenced shared bargaining but could not stop individual resignation. The result was a silent, mass exodus that left CTCs dangerously understaffed. Between June 2023 and June 2024 alone, the United Kingdom granted work visas to 35, 938 Zimbabweans, the vast majority being health and care workers. This migration stripped the public sector of its most experienced personnel exactly when they were needed to manage complex cholera cases involving severe dehydration and renal failure.

Those who remained faced working conditions that violated basic infection prevention and control (IPC) standards. Reports from the Zimbabwe Association of Doctors for Human Rights (ZADHR) indicated that nurses in rural hotspots like Buhera and Chegutu were forced to purchase their own personal protective equipment (PPE). In multiple verified instances at Parirenyatwa and Sally Mugabe Central Hospitals, staff worked without gloves or masks, exposing themselves to highly infectious cholera vibrio. The absence of linen meant patients lay on soiled beds, further propagating the pathogen within treatment facilities. This absence of resources turned hospitals into amplification nodes for the disease rather than centers of containment.

The government’s failure to disburse specific hazard allowances for the cholera outbreak further demoralized the workforce. Unlike the COVID-19 period, where a nominal allowance was standardized, the 2023-2024 response saw erratic payments. Treasury data reveals that while the Ministry of Finance announced a budget surplus, the Ministry of Health and Child Care had received only 26. 9% of its total annual budget allocation by the half of 2024. This fiscal bottleneck meant that funds for hazard pay and emergency staffing never reached the district level. Consequently, nurses worked double shifts to cover for emigrated colleagues without any additional financial compensation.

“We are not just fighting cholera; we are fighting a system that expects us to work on empty stomachs. A nurse cannot save a life when she is worrying about her own eviction. The government calls us essential, yet pays us as if we are invisible.” — Statement by the Zimbabwe Professional Nurses Union (ZPNU), February 2024.

The correlation between this wage suppression and the high Case Fatality Rate (CFR) of 2. 1% is undeniable. An underpaid, overworked, and under-equipped workforce cannot maintain the rigorous observation schedules required to save cholera patients from hypovolemic shock. In Chiredzi and Kuwadzana, patient-to-nurse ratios exceeded 30: 1 during peak infection waves, far above the World Health Organization’s recommended 6: 1 ratio for isolation wards. The “brain drain” is better described as a “brain push,” where skilled professionals were actively driven out by a state that refused to value their labor, leaving the nation’s poorest citizens to die in understaffed clinics.

13. The Blame Game: Central Government vs. Opposition Councils

The cholera emergency became a political football between the ZANU-PF central government and the CCC-led local municipalities. The Ministry of Local Government delayed budget approvals for opposition-run councils. Conversely the councils were accused of incompetence and failure to utilize available revenue streams.

President Emmerson Mnangagwa publicly censured urban councils in October 2023, attributing the resurgence of the pathogen to “mismanagement” and “unplanned settlements” under opposition control. This narrative was reinforced by Local Government Minister Daniel Garwe, who threatened to withhold future budget approvals for councils that failed to meet service delivery. Garwe specifically instances of fiscal irresponsibility, noting that the Chiredzi Town Council spent US$50, 000 on travel to Russia and South Korea while its workers went unpaid for months. The central government’s primary argument hinged on the collapse of the Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system in Harare, a failure that hemorrhaged millions in chance revenue that could have funded water treatment chemicals.

Harare City Council, led by Mayor Jacob Mafume, countered that the central government had systematically crippled municipal operations by withholding constitutionally mandated funds. Under Section 301(3) of the Constitution, the Treasury is required to allocate at least 5% of national revenues to local tiers of government. yet, verified fiscal data from 2023 reveals that the Treasury disbursed only 23% of the budgeted ZiG 193. 2 billion for devolution. In 2024, this figure marginally increased to 26% of the ZiG 4. 1 billion allocation. Mayor Mafume argued that these withheld funds, combined with the central government’s refusal to clear its own debts to the city—which stood at over ZWL$25 billion in October 2023—left municipalities financially paralyzed during the outbreak’s peak.

The Financial War: Lost Revenue vs. Withheld Support

The administrative deadlock created a vacuum where neither side took full financial responsibility for the collapsing water infrastructure. The following table contrasts the revenue losses by the central government against the funds withheld from local authorities.

The Auditor-General’s 2024 report further substantiated the chaos, revealing that 66 out of 92 local authorities failed to submit their accounts for audit. The report highlighted that Harare’s refusal to reinstate a functional ERP system since 2019 resulted in an estimated annual loss of US$60 to US$70 million. This administrative void meant the city collected less than half of its chance revenue, forcing it to rely on the erratic disbursements from the central government. Consequently, the “blame game” did not distract from the emergency; it directly defunded the response method required to stop it.

14. Donor Fatigue and the Trust Deficit

The financial architecture of Zimbabwe’s cholera response reveals a catastrophic breakdown in diplomatic trust. International donors have systematically dismantled direct budget support method, opting instead to channel funds exclusively through third-party implementers. This “bypass strategy” is not a procedural preference; it is a definitive vote of no confidence in the Ministry of Finance’s ability to manage public funds without leakage. By 2024, the government’s role in its own healthcare funding had been reduced to paying basic salaries, while the actual business of saving lives—procuring IV fluids, water treatment chemicals, and antibiotics—was outsourced to a parallel state of UN agencies and international NGOs.

The primary vehicle for this off-budget funding is the Health Resilience Fund (HRF), a pooled method supported by the European Union, the United Kingdom, Ireland, and Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance. Launched in 2023 with a budget of approximately $90 million, the HRF was designed specifically to keep donor money out of the government’s consolidated revenue fund. Instead, resources are managed by UNICEF, UNFPA, and the World Health Organization (WHO), who act as “technical partners.” While this arrangement secures the funds against theft, it imposes a heavy “mistrust tax” on the Zimbabwean population. Standard UN administrative fees deduct 7% of the total aid immediately for overhead, with further operational costs incurred as these agencies subcontract to international NGOs, who in turn subcontract to local partners. This cascading bureaucracy absorbs between 15% and 25% of the total aid value before a single cholera kit reaches a clinic.

The of this parallel system was laid bare during the 2023-2024 outbreak. When the pathogen began spreading in Chegutu in February 2023, the government did not have immediate access to a sovereign emergency fund. Instead, it was forced to wait for the of international appeals to grind into motion. UNICEF launched a specific cholera appeal for $10. 5 million, but by March 2024, it had received only $5. 2 million—a 50% funding gap that left millions of citizens during the outbreak’s peak. The reliance on “flash appeals” creates a deadly lag time; while diplomats negotiate pledge amounts in Harare, bacteria multiply in the contaminated wells of Buhera.

The situation sharply in early 2025, marking the onset of severe donor fatigue. After decades of plugging the gaps in Zimbabwe’s social services, Western governments began to withdraw. In March 2025, reports confirmed that the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) had terminated approximately $522 million in planned and active projects following a strategic review. This cut severed the lifeline for serious health programs, including malaria prevention and HIV support, which had long shielded the Zimbabwean health sector from total collapse. The withdrawal sent shockwaves through the NGO sector, forcing the closure of clinics and the retrenchment of thousands of health workers who had been on donor-funded payrolls.

This retreat coincides with a broader failure of humanitarian fundraising. The 2024 humanitarian appeal for Zimbabwe, which sought to address the twin crises of cholera and El Niño-induced drought, was only 24% funded by February 2025. The international community has grown weary of funding a emergency that appears to be the result of chronic governance failures rather than unavoidable natural disasters. Donors are no longer can to subsidize a government that purchases luxury vehicles for ministers while relying on foreign charity to treat cholera patients. The result is a “trust deficit” that has become a death sentence; as the safety net of international aid dissolves, the Zimbabwean state is left exposed, with no functional systems to replace the parallel structures it allowed to fester for twenty years.

15. The Vaccine Delay: Bureaucracy Over Immunity

The arrival of the Oral Cholera Vaccine (OCV) in Zimbabwe was a logistical failure defined by an eleven-month lag between the outbreak’s onset and the administration of the dose. While the cholera case was confirmed in Chegutu on February 12, 2023, the government did not launch its vaccination campaign until January 29, 2024. This delay allowed the pathogen to spread unchecked across all 10 provinces, infecting over 20, 000 citizens before the immunization drive began. The timeline reveals that administrative lethargy, rather than mere global supply chain constraints, was the primary driver of this catastrophe.

The specific metrics of the rollout expose the magnitude of the oversight. Zimbabwe targeted 2. 3 million people for vaccination to establish herd immunity in high-risk districts. yet, the International Coordinating Group (ICG) only released the batch of 892, 286 doses in late January 2024, forcing health officials to adopt a “phased method” that left millions during the peak infection window. By February 14, 2024, only 1. 5 million individuals—67% of the target—had received a dose. This shortfall compelled the Ministry of Health to switch from the standard two-dose regimen to a single-dose strategy, halving the duration of immunity provided to recipients in a desperate bid to stretch limited supplies.

Bureaucratic hesitation in declaring a state of emergency directly stalled the activation of international stockpiles. Although the outbreak raged through early 2023, the central government waited until November 17, 2023, to announce a state of emergency in the Harare Metropolitan province. This nine-month administrative gap was serious; the ICG requires a formal declaration and a detailed response plan before releasing emergency vaccine stockpiles. By failing to elevate the emergency status earlier, Zimbabwean officials locked the country out of the global queue during the months when the bacterium was seeding itself in the capital’s crumbling water infrastructure.

While global absence of the Euvichol-Plus vaccine were a reality, they served as a convenient shield for local incompetence. Neighboring nations with similar resource constraints managed to secure allocations faster by issuing timely emergency declarations. In Zimbabwe, the delay meant that the vaccination campaign commenced only after the death toll had already surpassed 400. The “reactive” nature of the campaign—launching nearly a year after the index case—meant the vaccines arrived too late to prevent the initial surge, functioning instead as a damage control measure for a disaster that was already out of hand.

The operational execution of the vaccine drive further highlighted the system’s fragility. The campaign focused on 26 high-risk districts, yet logistical bottlenecks slowed the distribution to remote areas in Manicaland and Masvingo. Even within Harare, the epicenter of the emergency, in suburbs like Kuwadzana faced long queues and sporadic availability. The reliance on a single-dose regimen, while necessary due to the delayed procurement, leaves the population with protection that wanes significantly after six months, setting the stage for future resurgence if water sanitation infrastructure remains unaddressed.

, the missed target of 2. 3 million vaccinations during the serious window was a failure of governance, not medicine. The data confirms that the tools to stop the dying were available globally, but the political can to access them was absent locally. The 11-month gap between the case and the vaccine represents a period where bureaucratic procedure was prioritized over human life, resulting in a preventable escalation of morbidity and mortality.

References

• UNICEF. (2024, January 29). Zimbabwe launches cholera vaccination to curb the spread.
• World Health Organization. (2024, August 9). Zimbabwe declares cholera outbreak over.
• Xinhua. (2024, January 24). Zimbabwe to start cholera vaccination campaign Monday.
• The Herald. (2024, February 6). One-third of target receive oral cholera vaccination.
• ReliefWeb. (2023, November 16). Zimbabwe Cholera Outbreak Emergency Appeal No. MDRZW021.

16. Infrastructure Decay: The 20-Year Maintenance Backlog

The physical catalyst for Zimbabwe’s cholera emergency lies buried three meters underground. The municipal water piping networks in Harare, Bulawayo, and Gweru have disintegrated, with the majority of infrastructure dating back to the colonial era of the 1960s and 1970s. These asbestos-cement and cast-iron pipes, which have a technical lifespan of 30 to 40 years, are operating two decades beyond their expiration date. The result is a system that functions less like a sealed delivery network and more like a sieve, mechanically ensuring that treated water never reaches the populations most to infection.

In 2024, the City of Harare admitted that non-revenue water (NRW)—treated water lost to physical leaks before reaching the consumer—had reached 60%. This metric indicates that for every 100 liters of water purified at the Morton Jaffray Waterworks, 60 liters are dumped directly into the soil through thousands of subterranean ruptures. In Bulawayo, the situation is statistically similar, with the local authority reporting a 48% loss rate in May 2024. This is not a resource management problem; it is a direct vector for disease. When water pressure drops due to these massive leaks, the empty pipes create a vacuum effect (negative pressure). In neighborhoods where sewer lines are also leaking—frequently running parallel to water mains—this vacuum sucks raw sewage into the drinking water supply. When pressure is restored, this fecal cocktail is pumped directly into household taps.

The financial of this decay are catastrophic. Harare spends approximately $2 million monthly on water treatment chemicals, including aluminum sulphate and chlorine gas, frequently imported at a premium. With a 60% loss rate, the municipality incinerates $1. 2 million of this monthly expenditure. In June 2024, official reports confirmed that Harare loses $4. 8 million annually specifically due to treated water sinking into the ground, a figure that does not account for the lost billing revenue which could fund repairs. Instead of capital investment, local authorities have relied on reactive maintenance—clamping individual bursts while the surrounding pipe sections crumble.

The of the required overhaul dwarfs the available budget allocations. In 2024, the Harare City Council allocated $216 million for water and sanitation, yet the bulk of these funds was absorbed by recurrent expenditures and chemical debts rather than pipe replacement. Bulawayo’s engineering department estimated in January 2025 that a complete overhaul of its water and sewer infrastructure would require $1 billion—a sum nearly four times the city’s entire annual budget. Consequently, the “maintenance” strategy remains limited to emergency patchworks. During the height of the outbreak in late 2023, municipal teams in Highfield and Budiriro were attending to over 200 pipe bursts per week, a rate of failure that made consistent system pressurization impossible.

This infrastructure collapse created the perfect biological conditions for Vibrio cholerae. The intermittent water supply forces to store water in open containers or resort to shallow, contaminated wells. Simultaneously, the absence of positive pressure in the mains allows groundwater—polluted by the 48% of sewage that also leaks from the sanitation network—to infiltrate the drinking water system. The government’s commitment in early 2025 to replace 6, 400 kilometers of pipeline acknowledges the severity of the emergency, yet for the 34, 550 victims of the 2023-2024 outbreak, this admission came twenty years too late.

17. Cross-Border Economics: The Regional Cost

The cholera outbreak in Zimbabwe ceased to be a purely domestic emergency in late 2023, metastasizing into a regional economic and diplomatic liability. As the pathogen crossed the Zambezi River, it relations with key trading partners like Zambia and Malawi, forcing the Southern African Development Community (SADC) to intervene. The economic was immediate: cross-border commerce, the lifeline for millions of Zimbabweans operating in the informal sector, was by sanitary cordons and import bans.

Neighboring governments, alarmed by Zimbabwe’s inability to contain the Vibrio cholerae bacterium, implemented rigorous defensive measures. By January 2024, the outbreak had spilled over into Zambia’s Copperbelt and Lusaka provinces, prompting President Hakainde Hichilema to take drastic action. The diplomatic tension culminated in an extraordinary SADC summit in February 2024, where regional leaders were forced to designate a “Cholera Champion” to coordinate a response that Zimbabwe’s own infrastructure had failed to manage.

The Stranglehold on Informal Trade

For Zimbabwe’s economy, which relies heavily on the informal sector—estimated by the African Development Bank to account for over 60% of GDP—the border restrictions were catastrophic. Informal Cross-Border Traders (ICBTs), 70% of whom are women, faced aggressive screening at major ports of entry including Chirundu, Victoria Falls, and Kariba. These traders, frequently moving perishable goods like fish and produce, were subjected to mandatory health checks that delayed transit times and increased spoilage rates.

Zambia’s response was particularly severe. To prevent further transmission, Zambian authorities enforced bans on street vending and the sale of fresh foods in border towns. This closed the market for Zimbabwean traders who rely on daily crossings to sell agricultural produce. In Namibia, a ban on perishable food imports from Zambia—triggered by the regional spread—further choked the supply chain, creating a domino effect that left Zimbabwean “runners” with unsellable stock and mounting debts.

Diplomatic and SADC Intervention

The outbreak tested the patience of the SADC bloc. While diplomatic language remained polite, the operational reality was one of containment and isolation. The SADC Secretariat’s intervention in February 2024 was a tacit admission that Zimbabwe’s domestic failure had become a regional security threat. The bloc was forced to mobilize resources for synchronized cross-border vaccination campaigns, diverting funds that were originally earmarked for long-term development projects.

At the Chirundu One-Stop Border Post, a serious artery for trade between South Africa and the rest of the continent, the efficiency gains of recent years were reversed. Health officials established screening points that created bottlenecks for commercial trucks. Drivers, already navigating a complex bureaucracy, faced additional delays that increased the cost of logistics. For the informal trader carrying goods by bus, the stigma was palpable; Zimbabwean travelers were frequently singled out for secondary screening, treating them as chance vectors of disease rather than economic partners.

The financial quantification of this disruption is clear. While the formal sector suffered from logistics delays, the informal sector—which operates on thin margins and daily turnover—faced ruin. The International Organization for Migration (IOM) noted that cross-border traders are sensitive to even minor disruptions; the weeks of intensified screening and market closures in Zambia wiped out the working capital of thousands of Zimbabwean families who rely on this trade to survive the country’s internal economic collapse.

18. The Auditor General’s Ignored Warnings

For over a decade, the Office of the Auditor General (OAG) has served as the sole reliable chronicler of Zimbabwe’s fiscal decay, yet its findings remain systematically disregarded by the Executive. Former Auditor General Mildred Chiri, who retired in 2023, produced a series of blistering reports that explicitly detailed the method of theft within the Ministry of Health and Child Care (MoHCC). Her warnings were not procedural; they were predictive. The financial gaps she identified—specifically regarding “direct payments” and emergency procurement—were the exact channels used to siphon funds during the 2023-2024 cholera emergency.

The continuity of this negligence was confirmed by Acting Auditor General Rheah Kujinga in her report for the financial year ended December 31, 2024. Released in June 2025, the document revealed a gap in government spending: Treasury made direct payments totaling USD 1. 98 billion to service providers on behalf of ministries, yet Ministries, Departments, and Agencies (MDAs) could only account for USD 1. 38 billion. This left approximately USD 597 million—nearly 30% of the total—completely for. In the context of a cholera outbreak requiring immediate disbursement for water treatment chemicals and oral rehydration salts, this “black box” accounting allowed millions to without a paper trail.

The “Pay and Don’t Supply” method

A recurring method of extraction identified by the OAG is the payment for goods that are never delivered. In her 2019 and 2020 reports, Chiri flagged that the MoHCC had paid over USD 2. 3 million for vehicles, medical equipment, and dental chairs that were never received. This precedent emboldened suppliers during the 2024 outbreak. The OAG’s 2024 findings exposed that Mpilo Central Hospital and United Bulawayo Hospitals (UBH) had inventory records in total disarray, with inventory worth over ZiG 161 million missing from Mpilo alone. Furthermore, the audit found that donations worth ZiG 2. 15 billion had no supporting documentation, erasing the audit trail for international aid meant to combat the epidemic.

The table summarizes the persistent red flags raised by the OAG regarding health sector spending, demonstrating a clear pattern of ignored recommendations that facilitated the 2024 emergency.

Institutional Paralysis and the Treasury Minutes

The failure to act on these findings is institutionalized through the “Treasury Minutes” process. By law, the Ministry of Finance must respond to the OAG’s recommendations with a plan of action. yet, these responses are frequently delayed or vacuous. The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) in Parliament has repeatedly summoned health officials to explain these discrepancies, but without the power to prosecute, their hearings amount to political theater. The 2024 audit noted that 66 out of 92 local authorities failed to even submit their financial statements for audit, a collapse in governance that made it impossible to track how municipalities used the emergency cholera funds allocated to them.

This culture of impunity had lethal consequences. When the cholera bacterium Vibrio cholerae began spreading in Chegutu and Harare, the procurement systems were already broken. The “emergency” nature of the outbreak was used to bypass the few remaining competitive bidding controls, replicating the looting frenzy seen during the Covid-19 pandemic. The OAG’s reports confirm that the government was not blindsided by a absence of resources, but by a deliberate refusal to close the financial drains it had known about for years.

References

Office of the Auditor-General Zimbabwe. (2019). Report of the Auditor-General for the Financial Year Ended December 31, 2018. Harare: Government Printer.

Office of the Auditor-General Zimbabwe. (2021). Report of the Auditor-General on the Management of Covid-19 Pandemic Financial Resources. Harare: Government Printer.

Office of the Auditor-General Zimbabwe. (2025). Report of the Auditor-General for the Financial Year Ended December 31, 2024. Harare: Government Printer.

Veritas Zimbabwe. (2025, October 9). Economic Governance Watch 3/2025: Financial Mismanagement. Retrieved from veritaszim. net.

Transparency International Zimbabwe. (2025). Trend Analysis Report: Procurement Performance in Zimbabwe’s Health Sector (2020-2024). Harare: TIZ.

New Zimbabwe. (2025, August 6). Auditor General’s Report: Over half a billion US dollars paid by Treasury for. Retrieved from newzimbabwe. com.

19. Weaponization of Health

The intersection of public health policy and political suppression became undeniable during the 2023 election pattern, as the Zimbabwe Republic Police (ZRP) systematically used cholera prevention to opposition campaigns. Between January and July 2023, the Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC) reported that police banned 92 of their planned rallies. In nearly every instance, authorities the Maintenance of Peace and Order Act (MOPA) alongside “sanitation concerns” related to the cholera outbreak, repurposing a biological emergency into a tool for electoral engineering.

The most instance of this selective enforcement occurred on July 9, 2023, just six weeks before the general election. Police prohibited the CCC from launching their campaign in Bindura, a town 88 kilometers north of Harare. The official prohibition order claimed the chosen venue—a bushy area near the town center—absence adequate toilet facilities and potable water, creating a “high risk” for communicable disease transmission. Authorities argued that the site’s poor road network would emergency services in the event of an outbreak, declaring the gathering a threat to public safety.

This justification collapsed under scrutiny when contrasted with the ruling party’s activities on the same weekend. While opposition supporters were barred from gathering in Bindura, President Emmerson Mnangagwa presided over a ZANU-PF rally in Magunje, where thousands of supporters were packed into a stadium with no social distancing enforcement. Independent monitors noted that the ruling party bussed in supporters from across the province, creating the exact high-density vector for transmission that police claimed to be preventing in Bindura. No health inspections were publicly recorded for the ZANU-PF venue, and no dispersal orders were issued even with the obvious violation of the very safety used to silence the opposition.

Legal experts argued that the police conflated the Public Health Act with security legislation to create an unassailable barrier to assembly. By classifying political rallies as “unsanitary gatherings,” the ZRP removed the possibility of legal recourse; courts were hesitant to overturn decisions framed as life-saving health interventions. This strategy allowed the state to freeze opposition mobilization in key constituencies like Masvingo and Manicaland, which were simultaneously the epicenters of the cholera outbreak and serious electoral battlegrounds.

The weaponization of these had a corrosive effect on the public’s reception of legitimate health directives. When the Ministry of Health later issued valid warnings regarding funeral gatherings and water safety, compliance in opposition strongholds plummeted. viewed the directives not as medical advice but as political tactics designed to curtail their movement. This skepticism severely contact tracing efforts in high-density suburbs like Glen View, where hid sick family members to avoid what they perceived as politically motivated police intrusion. The politicization of the epidemic did not just silence dissent; it actively accelerated the spread of the bacterium by severing the bond of trust required for community health management.

20. The 2026 Outlook: Structural Insolvency

As of February 14, 2026, the structural financial deficits that fueled the catastrophic 2023-2024 cholera outbreak remain unresolved. Harare City Council (HCC) is insolvent, operating without a functional Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system for the seventh consecutive year. The central government has failed to ring-fence water sanitation budgets in the 2025 National Budget, leaving the capital’s water infrastructure in a state of accelerated decay. Without a radical overhaul of municipal financing and procurement transparency, the large- outbreak is not a risk; it is a statistical certainty.

The financial paralysis of Harare is absolute. In January 2026, a formal petition was submitted to the Parliament of Zimbabwe calling for the immediate dissolution of the HCC administration, citing “organized financial mismanagement.” This follows the that the city has lost an estimated US$70 million annually due to revenue leakages and the absence of a verifiable billing system. The Auditor-General’s report for the financial year ended December 31, 2024, issued an adverse opinion on the city’s accounts, flagging missing payables listings amounting to billions in local currency and unsubstantiated liabilities. The city’s 2025 budget, proposed at US$548 million, was predicated on a drastic 188% tariff hike for low-density suburbs—a move rejected by who have not received consistent running water since 2022.

The central government’s 2025 National Budget, presented in November 2024, offered no salvation. even with the clear link between underfunding and the 718 deaths recorded in the previous outbreak, the allocation for water infrastructure projected a growth of only 3. 9%—a figure that fails to cover even the depreciation of existing assets. The Treasury did not ring-fence funds for water treatment chemicals, forcing the HCC to continue its perilous hand-to-mouth procurement strategy. As a result, water production at the Morton Jaffray Treatment Works averaged just 200 megaliters per day throughout 2025, against a daily demand of 1, 200 megaliters.

The “Silent” Resurgence: November 2024 – June 2025

While the government declared the major outbreak over in August 2024, official data confirms a “silent” resurgence began just three months later. Between November 2024 and June 30, 2025, Zimbabwe recorded 778 new cholera cases and 23 deaths. The Case Fatality Rate (CFR) for this period stood at 2. 9%, nearly triple the World Health Organization’s 1% benchmark. This resurgence was driven by the exact same factors as the 2023 disaster: dry taps, uncollected refuse, and the consumption of contaminated shallow well water in high-density suburbs like Budiriro and Glen View.

The refusal to address these solvency problem has created a permanent pathogen incubator. The 2025 budget analysis by the Zimbabwe Coalition on Debt and Development (ZIMCODD) highlighted that the allocation for health and child care declined to 10. 2%, missing the 15% Abuja Declaration target. Furthermore, the devolution funds promised to local authorities for water augmentation were largely undisbursed or diverted to non-essential recurrent expenditures. In 2025, the HCC spent only 10% of its targeted capital expenditure, meaning no new pipes were laid and no reservoirs were rehabilitated.

As the 2026 rainy season method, the conditions are identical to those that preceded the 2008 and 2023 catastrophes. The water account is not ring-fenced, meaning revenue from water bills is frequently used to pay administrative salaries rather than to buy aluminum sulphate and chlorine. The of Harare are trapped in a pattern where they are billed for water they do not receive, to fund a council that cannot account for the money, under a central government that refuses to intervene with the necessary capital investment. Until the financial governance of Zimbabwe’s water sector is depoliticized and professionalized, cholera can remain the country’s most faithful recurring visitor.

References

• Auditor-General of Zimbabwe. (2025). Report of the Auditor-General for the Financial Year Ended December 31, 2024 on Local Authorities. Harare: Office of the Auditor-General.
• UNICEF Zimbabwe. (2025). Humanitarian Situation Report No. 3: January – June 2025.
• Zimbabwe Coalition on Debt and Development (ZIMCODD). (2024). Analysis of the 2025 Executive National Budget.
• City of Harare. (2024). 2025 Budget Statement: Enhancing Service Delivery; Building a Sustainable Green Future Together.
• ReliefWeb. (2025). Zimbabwe Cholera 2025 – DREF Operation (MDRZW024).
• NewsDay Zimbabwe. (2025). Auditor-General exposes rot at Harare City Council. July 29, 2025.
• Spiked Media. (2026). Petition Seeks Dissolution of Harare City Council Administration and Forensic Investigation. January 23, 2026.

References

• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFe1AKqUzWWQUSv2a90FOWoncli_xEZRWyJXAc1EvPfK_o3yr4Xh2nuIyOxjvAKSi1QBrENb690PtNF53cmkDG5dfa677daQ_I-TUHcSYLbkmbsOgfiEjcss8DKF5yqQFZ2c1X8Y-JQ0gCnEVCCl8vWfvgYZRAhcv2VAP2–spJxPaq1jHcm-iAj0CoYWx1_xRDV0E0dHKMWlHrn_Nz6lfabKTknRIKoRO5usgH__1G1IrvXw==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFIw3F2aa5Q32suP22zCCUrXL2NyAfP_ALRBiHQpyaZWKGtmFXqSO7iYP_qg1kRuEIp5-lHheQF307FIjSpz3dDEjSf036dJpeo-4HryM3yrihgy3pc3cyq8E6eVkclBbt-8asOGqvvvorpyWiAwH4XCqx1MuZ2sPvz8N0jZ8WCHCJxNXzP2XlLRkGl87Ol26IytDcluUUNUbEz
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQF7MH-Bewrl8DVq4e_7kfq5jF-veBoIlJPH1soIp6L-OPolf6v71OZ9XMzXw6rRs4lF-EVCZxLtMyCI647i8YJtUo4lmkofHVxPevqT6C1JbNilZHX2X8MnQakOx86Pm1DxEYJBKmSPEf4vfwVGjvjcfQ2WpXpLCLcRnnE317TZsMzZ7JyizyyWnm3vghnJN2V0p2a1Irm6j2gHXuOS4LlmW3scvFPn7muOIA==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGs-C96qgWNWF9aoB8_a2KLYPbILrrDQqUcy5MQFE2Q3l3jjLcNFWSk0JTmEbFQpRom7CgbIVa63QkqoQI-TE1FuzB6Eez_mFEYj63FqyaSqpjbI0c_gwXVjzN_H43XYdZaX_RlCiQv7aTwgcBnClO3FCga8inZnLEhaba0UWrdpv-1UOuzfSFBY-wXxApSTsVNxXMERTqBp9w8RoaJmvEuNX7D
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGhKeI2ZhhOqfsbXSbh-1l23fzoE6YZtupHQmiw9IWju_fc2-7Urh4l0wGKcB9u0Tew5s0OslLoKjh3dmds5OCn9efwn8HK_Qc72ZTLxSSOBrwvgqJJh0tcBATpwY_APMWInGs7cIU5rNGbKSXJhy0ST5SzYOZNkH9CQeIAx-ZmvlELzfCemTHomDAT-IvU8jTAtKD9d4bhSJaG
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGkno92clUKKt2gxwgG92ZuAMWoKtw36kxWlS19_n2uBxk2of174z5fSEk_7_iQE4NOhu26nqCEoEP9ukJPYgXMx2N0vdCaBgB5lngC_85igOqs1u91l7QDwjyS_6Pk-Bd6blMQo2tq7NZ8thjIC-beku7zbcet2PuYGBjhggC52dLn9bU=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFxsO2T1YmTDEPR4u0gCxObIe04N9_nZ0V7OSNj16DvaYl5aTmMDRiZg09L56wZ1cb9QI7hrL35LNOuf_ZGGq1yzCJR4VZfIMI-kLgBtNSmiPAX-DrBWSCZA7f4Vcm-nUffqb_g990dGqKPzUQncLul6eKuDK9FZ4QlkYkHeULgcYSNd5sR_7Ms-vx6poEskR_yWw2AJiBDioYahJAJTDqmspUAfXj8H_dLJgjX-Dr9O5H-EoT4OfM=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQG56X4v3ukmJw2cB0OxSk6Aj-FhAj3K3SEkI_DTm7uaDXps0JVh_HjK3oeJvvBxurRh7n3xLpImygejwL_7yCIutK4Q5JseRlw5q6MA8pjMo-kgDubujZ2vAyaiir5pbF5Ij7kvU9102LL6-5NsMxGaoAnCTOkbfg6h27Erm4fXjZhAxaFUom5qIe7utrJAQN74XQP2gCHWOC9SzuCtf-W3TdOYrqb6zCd1ROX6z5X1QBDCRKI=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFjNbxGFJOggHzJ1iTF80Y8hiWzRV5DKM8LheUI1TzW-U_02nOcVHrOBL8XAIAMf1kZQ64vNT9xAZdZ5d_wWQEm3BmCzjYLuIeLhFKmK0AeP_gUJyzfBu0Mx4D1BJA5PiWgi_ixd1XF7ui9TDOhMPnGY_0m6uJrdcqA8ZUoGT_Nebunavb5CYdTktIg_Aq3OXM=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHo9xs-mDynmu14BG_MUjfBp121USs4QiOuhvnQKGF50Dkh_EqrGFEgR2fD7TtjM5HnLDj3KjZnJ2Q-b–cKizntbbowc4CX81TK61JECQlB0xMPcJH2ZEP6zT9Hwx8DKWjpKbCPzlKI6WBlm5tJiUUPbsoQC-Rk72mKYoeCAbiNRePUyTKyTmhz3icKd36gK0wEkI7Rzmo-Y2D8EhtNS2DLaQ=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFj7OxguurzwTttymIKuHwaE7La68EXInlHjl3_ln0OuNQNLlLbPE1_As7vJYzYLgtdRg22vXRHXhl1tIAHGhJyXjKpks5OFK6uZV-IuklwTT1naqlG-q3YH3iOboG66L88uS_rMWAL8buoSMj7gvnBu210k3DB0kw-SC-fB9xZ0CbX8pFq0N7KwCG5iqcuDKNBJDoa0QrOyODp_mVytCwcsb3ood8zAfHhVgi8JTlsLNw2
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQH3vKRLjfzGaxaFvtOsJ4a_AndmFMIoZL–H060SHdskZhl6MSlrUHC7xTQL89VDIDA-zep8RXLSJnKiKL6K_jXT7bq6OigZmBjHs5I7_ONymH-z0BTX3uEzqooqGb8V4AS1AMmkZbtjAMhOrl49paULU5ipju5k88qilZR_VY6UUWDV1gDTLzBC_47y_g6phKMvUU3AR4_ew90ReSQCKLtNjzUm9Ayh73v89fVmCQdTUBW
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFp4FTze4Asx_l-ozx0fJa1SQP10OiG4gzD_ZeMxMxdsu1g5ahyM5eGKjmvjJkOxjfkJzumkHvsypsmOsuxYjr9K9rltZyKIe-5P6nPX4AwmLHBocLzBUFiwqxPEslFHVa43gWlEovrNo4YjrOIRgQRzmQZ5IOSDRTexei5
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGEA9ZoTQu9yaa6gI_-NnsYPgDUNdQAsNppIntKIi5gpMmLRj7bEpnbBArIlHW1FldrQ3zQqUa4hYkCn8A8eRRgicixNKPG1-d9_TqBvxbyvGLo-iOn2MqsBjgWqjwZ6QW3krX4p8KnlyCoFIdd5grq5ZCTPee32FpGOk_h-AoiNO-WbGsHeODUO-6mCInZmt9VJUKno1YsSYKkvSeivj80JyyfTm1HYtZ8Sx8=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEhDmHK0nptQ7o_0xW2EN8y5OEQNCuDuqQahpa7_8MTuIBpveo0-uM8a4ZMj70hX-xgpA3Rmk0kQVVPdF3BWF-ucKSo_WGxIxxny21b2qogg_q-8PcmRZBTyU6cHg8k9WNVhk74gjBETi239rhxP4J2pP_sInm93bgvOj4=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGbjy0TH91C2ZOfWTDZiM5U3YpXQW9bEEuZusuFrbDm2PWni8mIM5cvn4AShAbD-7ziPat8zFG7roOppKbaAMWPSaQrm962sqUaxGOmX82r2Qtx-o5w42H57WkF_wkSNSsRq3HKZvv5xnigOUHAlpAObD4w-AjEf7wb6jETpoTTJEY7TUoJtQQXyepgF4Y_
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQF2d1A8QNU7EZY9t9oyXBIu2_B6QbSHlSIWbLYiw1M5lo2B_xzi4E323_2jf4VoXb4D_Ddy1MRr_B63mV07_lDc_ocGHrpo7O3GIWkBgQQZo8dzWt2EvFNH87ldTHijaO7fX4jbOpQMbpze
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEgll9olCajNbaMNmv1e8UB7IH2L_Dr_Kma28BSLvFUMB6M2dfWzUt0X19puVKpgNHMgMvGY-OggKTQSAPL7_z0Td7HVv6YOPbpgSuk9mmjDtnX9bJrYUFT6f4KXRm-vV3ZvRRt2vqHXECgeLdDEFw7c_UFz4gkrgOxJUrnJCCpuN1Gu9kiPsYrJ_I4rGfBPhp_zM_zzkfTF9w=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEZOL5ezVS7wlrYP26f3ODR7xggfZP4TFBJOzY5EyA17O788QMzqT27P1xJ89z1LJhNZ-rlINI51_tEkW484XatHWcYRqg54NRiXp_XtwJUA8saMh1Ls6XMwicv8FNGkYIdnuhA9h5P18C2zC7p18C9Xp0AMuCmri4Bz3Zt16x2Xi6U4qNxbcojzBolG7M=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFZlFIVtvb-UAORIIHLxwteIBsn88uzMHI5FMux8aHZ-8fzs1S6ZQ_B5kRx5V-Zhta-dO3BQOAYNCKab64uclyitp0z3OWAf0VXkJ596KRa8nuvGn3B3OfqhwGlT7LKFy4JNYg0uZfm–IAjaAd96EHPgeve3svqbkATfP91T0Pn7MlpIVzH3oxM7lB96HJjaz793KI
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHi4mbxWw-LeI00ZWN3yUyprPYXQTw9EBjZsCrgh1xpv_MqnfhNBYkERQS8TUx7aKMOveTsD1G7PIY-6f4Syy_ah0OxXL-UyzcsrXr2NbVxRdBsfG7FGSWbpXmoxYd3HJnw5kJy7H4T0jH58THfAkDxUVaTd5W57XI4OQ8=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHc327_JL22IWpvu3XprMWRuJo1xUXq3fP1i0hutlKMAzga_L09CHf2sTyCVGtd7qPn2RUAJrLg-89F0rp8xwS3LMokpZhQNPngYyQM0hmfebck8XL9JYBeQMwaIhHOdy5k3MAtqGYfdEwRFYvfg8uSDcOdmHpVT1e8JVejTZzrZ4aIDFl63gOInNtaU0dMDJ0qdYyqWw==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEWVxCCzT5Y1OTXn94W51-Z2Ta0zX5YgzE1ZsosxmrSHHu5KEJG0-lrx76ucopdjubqIpCiyWeB8EbiibAzFK-xLIxEltpEyObIR9FM4LFKYqbkhQvrtOYAFJ_HponwSJdMODmHu0MI6EQ6mhx-wF5xRO_IjmjaHCmrzWVWLfjpg8SnBx9yX8w8j0rUA4vaZDzK0K4Ft1Ic
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEgH0eJkiyrUpDbHS2Xi8FwHbvgftp5WBdDmQgqQoaU9nrcGQBAJOiT3OseMlxL0H6-MZkeWUIUxwXe-HA_3MiFIQ5cWOZ79q-4CNpA57I2L_p43ob3tvf4CAjZDiYSdc7oEWyFaMvVIFBxNnkGyVnnU4TyW7KgyDw-Pby0BUUgOombZ1VAANcmD98EwvPTSH5JCZXyugdIKT6c9g==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEoXrxlWbmPuIutQEdkQojDeWC6vIlFsd8-xIZ20HHnhZf_qSG9w3i097E6V7X66LK1uqcOkdU7SeVYJzge3hijL33ZI5Fv73C-pOU3IMR9tTDEIXZvEWM3dhVsGViYdW6DdAiZnDI-MpWI4nGXJ1cXIxHpAWOAxSn8Z-c=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEsuIdVghjSY1QKhQVLZsDjf6OFGWGQVN-qyCrj4X1y-Ja4ZgUmbRVK7MGNnzhiMV93NeW_CiBDFzbale0MjsoIdCIysMrEcDA1aOLqLdhRjY52Zj1LYmyVCjY61mmluMPvQyuXMwOLNem_-OL84DgfM9bo
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHH6z1CaXC1QDdftVCon_HZ7qLo5kCvDYbXSvTYQK0XfzH3PDVbJtuoM1rUgnkaZ-QTc0-qxQtmWvYklSu9d-oJ8US8tBv5fEpoVGULUUgVPEykwY3RO27UH-ciOCq7yh2Wo5ORCCBamSQX5cCMjg-kc3gZj0R_F9hZeU6nqGcUHfXb5Z2wUxEtnXZn5t98DojfWKA1RSxYwZppu2OalwBhrQj-sRys_LI6MzE8tafesFHf
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHQi8eJwY36IFYoLfL2lbW4Do77HND28AgPGNjn46lJJzmwKEm7GNS6hpDTcYYAEfS0B–KQec98x9x5khC7NI6VVo0MR1xXISALqr_LpRvPtDoRsFNvrSeZHqRjwnvSdbyhDWt9uUELU4ktOq5eqE9ZqvUUkXEqiWcVIfeoU8-O-Px1ny3gs1ZqELBcaQZXYcK1zb0LzRJNyE4LJ1p75hQD3vEj-GSJbfq6LgCcSQDT2w2r1GrUAN1
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHmmfk8ZJ0noEq5-KxDjWDNiLhlfpeAp7ZtHEQPQLjyPpD4JQDqC4KuI_FPhrxesmShL_AYD2uU3_C-jwiQumAdVSOgdYeOrZ8AYlFe6ghYKKqkiBD8mr6gAwtc8HG8qbLp8K0BVe01Tskzc_W64NzwGY7rWsdPnaObOBtAjZDKODwwdQhI1w8XF3haJSWej7C90bqkXNprmBjrpqE=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQH6dWyiordk0Cmoe_U2GVzXCIxxxfSseW7iEDlNnnfCZRZ0ELipVlwQD1sTRvhSOqku-BYB8oJdGCjAdeMXzkINEv4zBhWA95F2JUTiG5ehIC2yCebZpGBk67x0z0gP42OZMEGklBZW5xiYPhDCtEFvU_qNVmXJJre-nDifxJeKnrth9HLFlul4HKa-U6j2-qBB0n0ggP3-fnlPbBvjWLHxjyAGXUYN
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEmQBeXJ00_wE8dALg1vZ4WMnIGv98xv9xzpSpN_lkq1YGnmU2dHBPk8FEBS3YzWWNIsrRYa6tve4nJhN6tJjv4zkYvS80vYYi33CWRX9e2vhQDzc26HU77FkF985n3HjQT6pmslCv84oH3WzVaIcuhlLL13GVLGSD4TyBOdJGlG0jjilM6DA4wFznxon2lt6M7WOVHFLennFOvAXaP6QtsKawWowM7nvzxFdgov4kvBKSwqEvYLbigEg==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGXMz1Vb2LbfMcOP4YuHZrQpP5MuO6QBZClkLNnvVhcfnrScByBO6oPLCd4Ft0S_bVr2hHIOgw09tjEOG2ycztskjWObKwQBHyH0TWE-Th3SQGhSLLCnfRT3fSVkKXH_tv2CD4nVIBwV9paUguzULlfy3XOH074e4fmEzSk8CAksOEdPt1LuzFQn7Cv
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEjve7QhcV-it3bx9yGPfTmm2PNx26u6o5HpGrEFw5Gmx4lQGpq2X-Vi6CksJopngTJT7BE9w3XpJ_hAEMUdbrSI6BoWovBmwkVBMCLbB8XSRTTP6AvPTQaQCiJsjutG3IasM7xhsq49O-cqawgboXtCIZZ2TF1ZUmk3tOxpsXETdDXNuHCBI9_kZlGFYeoIx_qTK8qoH4rj7DeuRqDla5vWA==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGWDRo0PImd75dCR_FSdgVMAihKWcFCZaLwyUAxFRhxIxinhjolWY7oxpm_MCsSMg0v1BD2E9eE-sCKTx4tuTpKxPrgJsKONWcINMY_J4MdzVmnpEK7G0LCkxa0kQE8F2xGfv1a_ogHU5tLT1XI8XUAuQh3cY103YUhztTpoiAGEMo91bu9nn6LfrZhYfHcphRWa3ssw3FAAb4XogqgDvTgwhEO3hiN1PkbqV7A
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFOiDPzdC6Rr9XyvZY3ZMsnWhzKFR28gILANIWv5M_ijUbFvxZ4AU6BFEyKY4grKF0lV8qpcTyxMIpRBQEtSNgMSBQVhmeHZNx6ECFK0QZcPms49MUbv84ii1g_eyQIN4wxXy3Omvf7H9-BvFhK8hdNUgH4zu3V_9A1rc9Du5Bzf0-DxbU3y5dJ_AYQO7JrPNC0eL4zLktiRpDm2uEoAwH2D7bTg1dvW5QsGrY=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGfmsw3g85cqntIhE6tdEeJQgr6Whprfklzu8VmUvhTICmSbVoyREfJfNWhLWIozUxXtKDaivuV4fGaCLMosHQqveHzhFYORNaiiH1_ycjYgbkvIqOzLiXcJAgKOJaH1jFXrt15cu8sAvXDZNNFQZd1P4OjsA==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGcnMLF5maabrlPmz2RAw3VqvjC3BpA_eZGHLtmBbvP9Uv7iMe-PGIX4fTN-EWNAfWlYVI7qBu-qJeJvRQU1QG9IbFYLyU_i_07LbA6pYRKuobQO_1LebfCCXSsojgDFUqk-_uhZtVrhqIp-NTN9WBxyJOTiPhw
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFxTCvKNqMSOlNpxnTE74ef1KDfLyurTa_ezfQtstHqPoPEZrTigUmfoSvLho0EbpRbqTbTbXNNWAB39RqWu2z1XSSfuS6LVfbmCWlUr35rKy8tngEQGkjlzrUUMsFqDeUYxPHvfkQvusgSI_7i7PTW_Rq4stk4o92H-HKwEKzHO7Si6QetVQyUQOUmyt2oISnL_KVlHlK04l6RIxcWu-QKk2PEMLdJmzyIbjG6Z2H6xCdr2K2zxxByNK3B5aUdifCZ6R9fABpBC_Pz
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEXRLRb3oM6Swy6wdb-RVwtiRtBoBBzjM65uKlV2xyFnxCdFLvC55ZnI18BYW38-U5ajm4oRU5iWaFa6lLvu_zo_9ceBGw0wvobx40EQnYGSF-Yy88BA7pNfyHrjHcu54Wl7hJW4qvfp8UUDSURU_ygYQLsehuV-MeXWXzSaoNz3g==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGwuG4LkUtgyDwN3Tv-th10M7FH_Jma2YCMnNNmMXysk5ihHhkUVK597kLK834DgM27Dq5Bc7D2Tc9XYHqR53IYW_JHiSHT4ONrC6yrw_yzLH1dRKzjgVaBLgpBNFZUWpgSooPZeDv8EvYjP6IEzwCqzoCwqVkVYWMg3aqwG7zfUfLbYdl5thJjXdvX_tya2L_46SM3fNuJERKF0G6ZN0_RLex6Ef6_oyRnkkhm4ioO4c6W-aw=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHkPvowcDKHi4xBGdq0q-d5zzXhDxd6VZWg-jbSOL2I1DOv3Mc8rHZvjJm5s08CTWDVJXCM8PhEE_30d2Pb96tVYx_bz1lqTfT-9VeKa-ErakbLlMX8swUkExgqo7Z8-mxrNbzThx1nMugymNWwtl8bYbPvs-a3UKymbhos9tNBdlx1Wg==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGEI25ku3ZnpELx3yweMh9vPri5ISKMLRJs-tllvlSzLbyTcRYSkIcQGhAeCgGPJwBCZq3qTS8Dtk1SD6_Vz01rFRpoIm91wuiOyuUxJ80S1MNgeAcYFdhCh5k=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGBPfX674bMZqlbC-q0xvZCUP4-MZhXFXr2zLUNr5NS229_wXZaHG3Rz9ohehGeNigQwnwQXBnsMNlqqNTywP7BGqsyrI6x8oTeU14IXp-cfDDR76b1usFzskRYZGGCO2aL986gGTi_W3NdoitpA6R7oXNsWlHVn00HOam0YnY-DELWSzV6
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQH090FzzNufEPnxF1Khr2_DsN4WP3U3XC2d_QFpZO6N0xlsfRaSNkMxIhbSos74r2esZHcZxZSMy_MNv6rc8x7KiEff3I3n-mOklYYtX1BlQsMLl6iN4C3gOefL1cBXln7_wxjIDXOLq9d_xxUWx4W7iDbhJuqlb_KE8rC1zvPxsIUkCJ9MifeA10jenjP_t-7z9zcvrIWG
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQH4s-Sy1-qhERKvmEl9i2MPcO5dAGXVsbvlOK62xn-S7q-dp4EVUKPgncaK1LAEd6bfBg2MFE7l8iV0i5LQ5Rq5dA6MxsXM0q8CWe0O8k5jsRv56ImTUxure6KI8Bud3KoXJzechqJDK9MZ9S8UrEGJPvwj-2KZOgFQP3FwoCf2rSl1bvsoN21sq76HNc4DQrev6yupukNjLoRVYSidn8sI76OeXfS3vOqwDM5o7TrvWyIRMjRlvNqjZvCH22Q=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQE6lrrBzj3KfYdtMnvRqsY9WVrunKlKDDEFWHcgQnFD2vJ1VJ6u2YWcdEHghw8NO4QiuQ-XwQnEBLASdpxNaHrHmnYkPU9ZtttwF2X8REmOWFA-xcCbsKQfyqEH-a46oU-2Le-DcKurSKtpQewGILwlysrM7DtHy7ElBAI0M4T_uQdYlwi44q6yF8XxbftjtUPMiyyt7A3J-sww8mBM34jwCkOr_fdM
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQG7m9X1A4IACqhxqc178jnfbvkub0xzpCeWCMvbmHdzQgVKDsIDzNEFugG6HIuPrEb6q7NY60-TWAbUMoMsutrt_-C4C45Ji-6HGDxLN0DNagMblOLRdDmKIrVUF8ZePDi-ZeqLZmg6WZmrkLsWeNfq5c8xqQjwwwdHJ9FJU2-YA_lxXPI7UEBFz8ESyABrhn8gAacoAJrGnd5pNvuY3HHBgSyQLjEKjsTcTgnKrVFBUda5
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHhYZ8Co91AcF_NpIZZ9PInXsH8JxAOey0ID0TQFubePwfgAap07GSEgQUoSYT9dc5hFK5ihULUK7IygMtdfM7WOMro4MXrEa7xzwwCy8v1xwKuAZeqr8zDdXmOZ47-ID4d1sE0CHp0xw==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHmEk3hC1D4HEC4AzX8Jei8kZ-doR3gncQHrLrUGXqZJyG2u082fQ8khwm1XHO4xx_9HhBqiqWw0Ypc_CP-VSP7gQaZZBXUbkhAR38LCxaqHsowVBgb95wFSef_zl_kkHPlw2dy2QJXRA7DJ0g-ynUTm5x-uxRIfFtoJiiVmOD91v95u2pSnox2oPUZjpMK8SvWcpbCNMOqSHhO5Y4xt3iJTe0MkdPIQqy4FaxEmUklVK4IUA==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQH6LIU1PuP-saMmXNCa2UdUSt2UWutDUOboPG6GtvZZby-3aZ7PzZBnGJXv1iyZpoElRi97ARAT1kWNUsGYz6luQOTQcs-5RSi4-5yN4AwzQai-ekPPlTHFvx0-W4Ix_Qte9WMUzFiC4tzlzrbfaQekC0U3WhDDY8FK1RzzNZ-om8pJToaVzU93GllBCA6Uq3yevtZKBw==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFhQhM8SRmwxUUEQWo97A8QlugBpRfJcMzXd7r0_DuNyK_vNRw5ESm6hg8Ey3g1VWOS2P2qOmH_xY7cc4CgOzW7nfVcHD9jOUwA_SQLp81gH5lnEZYDg2Up9fSo5nX_WX_GBQmqAKceCx6h-ocZTQ==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFgFXOwpiH9dZ5Xsn33cXMlsamgxq-asLj6x5qFoGnW1IN9ydm1guORUXYz-clR6BscXFwDSxYMtIwGTeBerV2clPbPUVwPXl6StT_LGl-oM-LW9m_zTuxO5uHL68FOUW-fAHDqrCkyHXneS0gNWOCfnP-sbmWs99epqeOBowZfsOxWKBfr4wPu
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGCMMzwPGumFg9-shWANse22f5WuCTC0VHgHcrGS_MCMnb0_y4ZYG0XGJ6eAVrP-Csys72fpZkU58kdc3qPleG7a_rFZ1TaAcDshBAtSIAeKeMEfRSltVrezKJ6n3-c0BjNh-MshmDUMKRjkh0HpKJV-08ckfdMUxict5UglXzmGDc=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHoXxrzWiViBL3slkgA5mfy-e2StWpliaysddZfcGaefHdzM5w0vjrFiP2-M33_MXkLCM7NBUH-Jk9-5HHS50gIIkvA_6PZRh_t6LCRbis_ch6fla-7xzJuhiULiIyWPXW7UXV4By3rw_5BGKBpQpG5cN7zrctUxW1KX_Madp0F3Eov4_Bc0cj8Tbdm6Qd3rpMrgQRhbaby8b9sNWAwfAq_Itv5ehRzpVDRYG35cPRudUpdaAc=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQHtvdgRprA1-mq38CUjY_HyXD_KRcYiOKqR36dN-0J0uy9HTuvoQwvlmrwyKkCJnm5EHBJEznWOODAYaEMziHHhFrufMtUEp1BGx0cyLgh-pqG81r-VTS0vZs6uzLGobk003ZkSMdXsxWy7gE8MgpQ35MIldpvMfPvtLt2TW7s=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQERNm6CyF7ywitzsNDx_CHpTigLdCCMQdBIFyk6MALbUomh7_x-sHc5LykcMbSqSVI40s_SicXpE7oKgglnlCJQupEXcpfzhJydWwATqnijng4AekhfKb65qplACGjHVI0N13y8KfVh_3qLjTEWK3E2tDvYKT0JAruU7HnjU8lRKO2a64rZTg==
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQGfAsRMbfT4uBq-c4PNGIsx_SMdsotq5rEHUaWmoOMKZCfqPxqnQ2lf3cCm5TWu2HWjv_wc9VEQ-rkqejbxYRxv1PPpqM5nC_G4HCjA6ZMZNIRl98eI7HRUtyQh1NuECr80wYQ_N869kGjumgLRC9__cGs1z3ZJYv6h9lzC3XWFpnUFDzGvSMkwGodsXWB6Bug3LaqqonmbKwy6-wWodHhqEWNZSQ2xdtRZ5khfMVFscQgicslR43GowfqBJvAc
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQG7Mr6zjnAPCZBd0qScTx-ciOcGKeLTI1atjLWmuy-K6HcUUfrPa9rrH2tg6JoUa5Hh_MMlkwcRu16bco1k1AhUkPRHLxj-H6ZpdfDKKeT3dfb7J3jCt_UoC8zy8LhAj_Ckh-iafMhGPngZ
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQEdDG3VJWdJh3E_dp28CdjAy6iitDx8a-7vMN8NBIRxeinpZllBmZizwzFjLOFb5-kR3PbSw1_8oSlD1VxsrMcMcNuEgK-l_YuNAJ-xXRT6zAvgwxutOdQp_ZKRRrk7V_F-T9FKO91Ukj4KGA6ID4IQTkepjkSIc6na8ADW5q8=
• https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AUZIYQFpTDiAQbRcAMpdErccj4ub5i6BhjLzor7alQaWALWsrh8DrKIgAtC71YEJXEB9p7kk4WVjRYy90RbLn6PwtwcyuHd5pBCkSu0bWNle6Xk4ljcAKFVWUIzT7kiADL-1Poc1J1UA6mYyoC2OWvUKdxmUg2pcHj2YYaQPsVvJLQuLg8KO2HKc6yHe5957-tmDrPpyCeSpkejHSCvWBuB-P7xXrEELUw==